Silhouette or No Silhouette?

I went on another summer afternoon hike at my favorite wildlife refuge, I didn’t have a particular plan other than to shoot some photos even if they weren’t good. The wildlife refuge is very dry this time of year, the wildflowers are gone, the creek isn’t flowing, and there are few people out there. I hiked past a group taking family pictures and had the rest of the park to myself.

The grasses and spent wildflowers were all fading yellow from the rainless summer but I think they still catch the late afternoon light in a nice way. The challenge in photographing them is that they look the best when viewed from directly opposite the low hanging sun. This means that you are shooting directly into the sunlight and even if the sun is not in the frame, the light on the lens still tends to wash out the image. To deal with this, I used a long focal length and zoomed in with the lens hood hopefully shading the glass from direct sunlight. I picked out a distant prickly pear surrounded by the spent wildflowers, got down really low, and worked on that for a composition. My result below.

The fringes of the fuzzy spent wildflowers catch a lot of sunlight and create a nice pattern, I think. The cactus is really just there to give you something to look at in the pattern. I added a radial vignette mask around the image to slightly reduce exposure and de-clarify so that attention is drawn in toward the center of the image. I think the photo conveys the feeling of a dry, late summer afternoon. What do you think?

I wandered around waiting for the sun to get lower. There were a lot of high clouds and I thought it might get pretty, but I could eventually see some heavier clouds on the horizon and knew that sunset would be a dud. But eventually the sun peeked through a gap in the clouds before being hidden for good and I targeted a lifeless tree on the edge of the ridge looking west for a silhouette photo. My goal here was to have all of the tree’s branches against the sky and the entire landscape nothing but a silhouette. I shot the sun on the edge of the tree to try to get a little bit of a sun-star. My silhouette is below.

I like the silhouette as it is almost an abstract photo. I think that with the sun still in the sky it does look a bit unnatural and the effect might be better during twilight when the sky is a deeper blue. So, I also made a version in which I didn’t darken the landscape and maybe I like it better. The sun-star is nicer and you can see a little texture in the tree. The non-darkened version is below. What do you think?

And lastly, just a little heart-shaped cactus. Thanks for reading.

15 thoughts on “Silhouette or No Silhouette?

  1. The narrow depth-of-field works well on the first one. I realize that aside from drawing my attention toward the prickly heart, it works to move my mind into the imaginary space beyond the top of the frame. I probably prefer the silhouetted tree for the same reason. Very “Japanese” I suppose, to fill an empty space with something imagined, or merely felt… “ma” ( 間 ).

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I like the silhouette best, as it conveys a peaceful, twilight feeling. The heart-shaped cactus reminds me what a thorny time that Valentine’s Day can be. I have to be very careful when choosing the greeting card for my wife.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. I LOVE the way the “spent wildflowers” glowed in the silhouette of the cactus in the first picture. I really liked that one.

    Of the two tree and sunset pictures, I guess I prefer the one that has the most definition (the second one) but I honestly like both of them.

    Thanks for the heart shaped cactus for a closer :).

    Liked by 1 person

  4. What a nice surprise to end the day. Silhouettes are great, and heart shaped things always appeal to my sentimental heart, but the wildflowers photo I love! At first glance and before reading, I thought it was hundreds of fireflies. Beautiful.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Nadine Gordon Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.